Is $1,933 monthly for rent cheap? It's ludicrous to call Columbus affordable

In an article published online March 21, the Columbus Dispatch cited a Realtor.com study that asserted Columbus is the second-most-affordable large city in the country for renters and that we should be willing to accept $1,933 per-month rent as “affordable.”

On behalf of the Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio, I disagree.

Emphatically.

As Mayor Andrew Ginther, the Dispatch Editorial Board, and many others with actual, on the ground experience in central Ohio noted recently, the housing burden thousands of our neighbors face is real and it is growing.

Expecting workers earning less than $15 per hour, let alone retirees, to fork over three-quarters of their income for housing is ludicrous. Calling it “affordable” considerably misses the mark.

The demand for affordable housing is at an all-time high and far exceeds the number of units being built or preserved as affordable in the region and throughout Ohio.

The study came to what we feel are erroneous conclusions by assuming that renters would have the same median income as homeowners. They clearly don’t. Other, more reliable, studies show only 30 affordable housing units are available for every 100 extremely low-income households in the greater Columbus area.

Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio,estimates 54,000 low- and moderate-income households in Franklin County pay more than half their income towards housing costs. A Building Industry Association study from 2020 – before the region’s welcomed job gains were announced – concluded that we need to build 14,000 to 21,000 new homes per year just to keep up with growth.

Yet I believe Columbus is poised for extraordinary success to overcome these challenges.

Ginther is leading a housing strategy, Columbus City Council is advancing legislative solutions, leaders across the region are uniting behind a housing coalition, and state officials are crafting powerful housing incentives, such as a new Workforce Housing Credit that will help build “missing middle” apartments that cater to the employees of our future and their families.

We cannot be complacent. With growth coming to Central Ohio, more housing—and more affordable housing—is essential.

As Ginther noted, “as we grow, housing must be the priority, not an afterthought.”

Two decades ago, Austin, Seattle, and Nashville were trendy communities with affordable homes and a wait-and-see attitude. Unfortunately, they let the opportunity to promote safe, quality and affordable housing that serves a range of incomes slip away. We simply cannot make that same mistake.

Together, as a region, we must raise the resources to expand affordability, modernize our land use and zoning laws to grow our homes at the same pace we’re growing our economy, help the next generation unlock the power of homeownership, and ensure that the most vulnerable among us always have a place to call home.

Bob Bitzenhofer is chair of the Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio, a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization dedicated to protecting and promoting housing affordability across the region.

Central Ohioans being 'priced out' of homes; Record number of evictions in Franklin County

COLUMBUS, Ohio (WSYX) — A record number of evictions were filed in Franklin County in 2022, with almost 21,000 people losing their homes.

Michael Wilkos, senior vice president of community impact with the United Way of Central Ohio, said that number is up 41% from 2021 when 13,500 eviction complaints were filed.

He said city leaders should be concerned.


Officials work to help Ohio families sacrificing to have housing

Finding affordable housing is becoming increasingly challenging for some Ohioans. Mike Kallmeyer sat down with Carlie Boos, executive director of the Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio, to learn more about the barriers families face with housing.

“It’s terrifying, if you are paying more than half of your income towards housing you are by definition sacrificing something for that,” Boos said.

Those sacrifices often include adequate food, medical care, or time with family because of a parent working several jobs. Boos also talked with Kallmeyer about immediate and long-term solutions to affordable housing.

“I think that this is a really scary spot to be in as a country. We have never been this far in the hole,” she said.

Despite challenges, Boos described hope for central Ohio because of a bond investment supported by Columbus Mayor Andrew Ginther.


Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio names new board chairman

The Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio (AHACO) selected Columbus Metropolitan Housing Authority vice president of planning and development Bob Bitzenhofer as the alliance’s new chair of its board of directors.

Bitzenhofer replaces previous AHACO Board Chair Michelle Heritage, who retired last year as CEO of the Community Shelter Board.

The alliance also announced:

  • E.J. Thomas, the AHACO’s founding chair and president and CEO of Habitat for Humanity – MidOhio, will serve as the AHACO board’s vice-chair.

  • Leah Evans, president and CEO of Homeport, will serve as the AHACO board’s secretary.

  • Amy Rosenthal, vice president of affordable housing at National Church Residences, will assume the role of AHACO’s treasurer.

  • Impact Community Action (IMPACT) CEO Bo Chilton and Creative Housing | Creative Renovations CEO Cristy “Critty” Buenconsejo have been selected as new directors to AHACO’s nine-member board.

  • Columbus-based nonprofit Homes for Families also has joined AHACO as a new member, bringing AHACO’s total roster to 29 organizations.

AHACO members represent the continuum of local and national housing experts including homeless advocates, emergency service providers, housing developers, homeownership proponents, lenders, and the philanthropic community.


Voters Approved Millions for Affordable Housing. Advocates Say Congress Should Do the Same.

Voters in Colorado and nine cities across the county approved housing affordability measures in November. The efforts sought to finance the construction of affordable housing, preserve existing rental properties and support renters.

[…]

Columbus, Ohio, voters OK’d $200 million to go toward the building of more affordable rentals, efforts to house and assist the homeless and the preservation of existing affordable housing, as well as funds to make homeownership more affordable in the area.

“These bond issues are one way to address [affordable housing], but they’re also a political indication of the degree to which voters recognize there’s a problem that has to be solved,” said David Dworkin, president and CEO of the National Housing Conference. “When we look at the broad range of proposals that have been approved, I think we also can see a signal that people get it. There’s a problem. And we’re going to have to pay to help fix it and it’s not going to fix itself now.”

Carlie Boos, executive director of the Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio, said that inflation has created an “immediate need” for the affordable housing bonds. People are overcrowding their apartments to cover rent and the length of stay in homeless shelters is getting longer as families have nowhere to go, Boos said.

“The way that inflation is pinching everybody’s budget is making construction and building for housing demand harder and harder to do. So there’s an immediate need,” she said.


Intel’s plan for a $20B chipmaking hub in Ohio means an affordable housing problem: ‘Where are we putting everybody?’

Intel’s announcement earlier this year of a $20 billion manufacturing operation bringing thousands of jobs to rural Ohio was greeted as an economic boon.

But behind that enthusiasm lurked a pressing question.

“Where are we putting everybody?” asked Melissa Humbert-Washington, vice president of programs and services at Homes for Families, which helps low-wage workers find housing in a region already suffering a major shortage.


Columbus voters approve affordable housing, other bonds

Voters approved Columbus' $200 million bond package for affordable housing that Mayor Andrew J. Ginther and other city officials say will provide funding for homes for lower-income residents in a market quickly becoming too-expensive for many.


Carlie Boos, executive director of the Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio, said the vote on the affordable housing issue shows that there's a clear mandate for affordable housing.

"If there are any local leaders wondering if now was the right time to step up for affordable housing, I think now they have an undeniable answer," Boos said.


The Punch List: How public-private partnerships help revitalize communities

Our latest cover story looks at the transformation happening in Franklinton, which until recently seemed frozen in time, with little to no development or new businesses moving into the area.

In 2004, a massive floodwall was finished and the neighborhood was primed for new development. But it didn’t come immediately.

Change didn't come to the neighborhood until the private sector and some passionate neighborhood advocates and neighborhood organizations came together.

'Lifting Linden,' Columbus leaders, Linden neighbors discuss progress of community plan

COLUMBUS, Ohio (WSYX) — Thursday night, Linden residents learned how over $21 million of grant money had been used to elevate their neighborhood over the last three years.

The City of Columbus joins the Linden community and community partners on Thursday at the Linden Community Center to celebrate The 614 for Linden, a collaborative to advance the One Linden Community Plan. The collaborative, named for six nonprofits, partnered with four community development financial institutions to have a positive and significant impact on one neighborhood.


How foresight in public affairs can ensure the promise and potential of Intel in central Ohio

The local housing market already shows effects that the potential influx of new Intel employees brings for supply and demand and pricing.

“One of the awesome things about Intel is it’s going to raise property values; one of the scary things about Intel is it’s going to raise property values,” said Stephanie Moulton, a Glenn College professor whose expertise includes housing and consumer finance.

“For people who already own homes, this is a good thing. But for people who haven’t yet purchased homes, already the Columbus housing market is one of strongest in the country in terms of our house price growth,” she said. “Prices have just boomed since COVID, and the population is growing, which means demand for housing and homes is increasing and supply can’t keep up with that demand, so you end up having really high prices.

“I think about the missing middle and first-time homeowners,” Moulton says. “How do we make sure there are on-ramps for new homeowners into the market? That’s going to be challenging without investment. There are things Intel could do to create on-ramps.”

Some solutions: subsidies; strategic housing development with various home price points; and help from nonprofits such as NeighborWorks, the Mid-Ohio Regional Planning Commission, Ohio Housing Financing Agency and the Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio, which have expertise on how to serve people across the income spectrum.

“It’s making sure those players are at the table and part of the discussion so they can help,” Moulton said.